10 Auto Insurance Providers for Drivers with Bad Credit
Image Source: pexels
Drivers with bad credit usually pay much higher car insurance costs, making it essential to find the best auto insurance for drivers with bad credit. In Michigan, drivers with low credit pay 263% more than those with great credit. Across the U.S., drivers with bad credit paid $4,145 on average in 2023, which is $2,198 more than drivers with excellent credit. Choosing the right car insurance can help lower these costs significantly.
Key Takeaways
-
Drivers with poor credit can save by checking many insurance quotes. Different companies have different prices, so get at least three quotes.
-
Search for discounts and bundle deals to cut costs. Safe driving, using anti-theft tools, and combining plans can save money.
- Better credit scores can mean cheaper insurance. Pay bills on time, lower credit card debt, and fix mistakes on your credit report to improve your score.
Top 10 Auto Insurance Providers for Drivers with Bad Credit
1. Geico – Best for Overall Affordability
Geico is known for its low prices, even for drivers with bad credit. They offer many discounts, like safe driving and bundling policies. You can also save with vehicle safety features. Geico’s website and tools are easy to use. Drivers can manage accounts and compare prices quickly. Its low costs and ease of use make it a top choice.
2. COUNTRY Financial – Best for Discounts and Bundling
COUNTRY Financial has many discounts to help lower costs. Drivers can save by combining auto insurance with home or life insurance. Safe drivers and those with anti-theft devices also get discounts. These savings make COUNTRY Financial a good pick for drivers on a budget.
3. Mile Auto – Best for Low-Mileage Drivers
Mile Auto is great for people who drive less. This company charges based on how much you drive. Drivers send a photo of their odometer each month to calculate their bill. This method helps low-mileage drivers save money on insurance.
4. Nationwide – Best for Broad Availability
Nationwide offers insurance in almost every state. They provide discounts for good students, safe drivers, and bundling policies. The company is financially strong and has good customer service. These features make it a solid choice for drivers with bad credit.
5. Auto-Owners Insurance – Best for Customer Satisfaction
Auto-Owners Insurance is highly rated for happy customers. They work with local agents to give personal advice to drivers. Discounts are available for safe driving, paperless billing, and bundling policies. This focus on service makes them a great option.
6. Amica – Best for Competitive Rates
Amica offers low prices and great customer service. Drivers with bad credit can get loyalty discounts and accident forgiveness. Flexible payment plans make managing bills easier. Amica’s focus on affordability and service makes it a strong contender.
7. Travelers – Best for High-Risk Drivers
Travelers helps high-risk drivers, including those with bad credit. They offer discounts for hybrid cars, safe driving, and bundling policies. With years of experience, Travelers provides reliable coverage for all drivers.
8. The General – Best for Flexible Payment Options
The General is a good choice for flexible payment plans. Drivers can pay monthly, in full, or with credit cards. Other options include electronic checks and automatic payments. This flexibility helps drivers with tight budgets.
9. CURE – Best for No Credit Check Policies
CURE doesn’t use credit scores to set prices. Instead, they look at driving history and other factors. This makes it fair for drivers with bad credit. CURE is a great option for those who want fair pricing.
10. Dillo – Best for Drivers with No Credit History
Dillo helps drivers with no credit or poor credit. Their policies are simple and have few requirements. This makes them easy to understand and affordable. Dillo is a good choice for new drivers needing insurance.
Criteria for Selection
The following table shows how these providers were chosen:
Criteria Description Rates based on credit scores Companies charge different rates depending on credit scores. Availability of discounts Discounts can make insurance more affordable for drivers. Customer service ratings Good customer service means better help for policyholders. Overall affordability Policies must be affordable for drivers with bad credit.
How Credit Scores Affect Car Insurance Costs
Why Do Insurers Check Credit Scores?
Insurance companies check credit scores to guess if drivers might file claims. A credit score shows how responsible someone is with money. Insurers think this connects to how safely someone drives. Drivers with good credit are seen as safer, while those with bad credit may pay more. This helps insurers decide risks and set fair prices for everyone.
Link Between Credit Scores and Risk
Studies prove credit scores and driving risks are connected. Drivers with bad credit often brake hard or speed up quickly. These actions can lead to more accidents. The American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA) says drivers with the worst credit cost 28% more to insure than those with the best credit. Insurers also use data showing bad credit predicts bigger losses.
| Evidence Type | Key Findings |
|---|---|
| Data from insurance companies | Bad credit links to risky driving, like sudden braking or speeding up. |
| APCIA research | Drivers with the worst credit cost 28% more to insure. |
| Past studies | Lower credit scores mean higher chances of losses for insurers. |
States That Limit Credit Score Use
Some states have rules stopping insurers from using credit scores to set rates. These laws protect people from unfair pricing. States like California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan don’t allow credit scores for car insurance. Oregon and Utah also stop credit info from being the only reason for denying or canceling policies.
Note: Eight states, such as Nevada and Maryland, have strict rules on using credit scores for car insurance. These laws help make prices fairer for people with bad or no credit.
Knowing how credit scores affect costs can help drivers find better insurance options.
Auto Insurance Companies That Don’t Use Credit Scores
Overview of No-Credit-Check Insurance Providers
Some car insurance companies don’t use credit scores for pricing. Instead, they look at driving history, car type, and location. Companies like CURE, Dillo, and Empower offer these policies. But, they are only available in certain areas. States like California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts have laws banning credit score use for car insurance rates.
These companies aim to make prices fair for people with bad or no credit. They often help high-risk drivers or those who struggle to get regular insurance. While they don’t cover the whole country, they are helpful for drivers in eligible states.
Pros and Cons of Choosing These Companies
Picking a no-credit-check insurance company has some benefits. Drivers with bad credit avoid extra costs from traditional insurers. These companies focus on driving habits, not financial history. In states with credit score limits, these policies follow local rules and treat drivers fairly.
But there are downsides too. These companies are not available everywhere, limiting choices. Their rates can be higher since they cover riskier drivers. Also, they may not offer as many discounts or resources as bigger companies.
Tip: Compare quotes from different companies to find the best deal.
Tips for Finding Affordable Auto Insurance with Bad Credit
Compare Quotes from Different Companies
Getting quotes from several insurers helps find cheaper options. Each company calculates prices differently, so costs can vary a lot. Drivers with bad credit should get at least three quotes. Online tools and comparison websites make this simple. Checking multiple options helps find the best auto insurance for drivers with bad credit that matches their budget.
Search for Discounts and Bundling Deals
Many insurers offer discounts to lower costs. Safe driving, using anti-theft devices, or choosing paperless billing can save money. Bundling car insurance with home or renters insurance can also reduce costs. Drivers should ask about all discounts to save as much as possible.
Choose Higher Deductibles to Save Money
Picking a higher deductible can lower monthly payments. A higher deductible means paying more if there’s an accident, but it reduces the policy cost. This works well for drivers who rarely file claims. Make sure the deductible is affordable in case of an accident.
Get Help from an Independent Insurance Agent
Independent agents can help find affordable insurance. They work with many companies and suggest policies that fit your needs. Agents know which insurers offer good rates for drivers with bad credit. Their advice can save time and help find the best deal.
Tip: Programs that track driving habits can reward safe drivers. These programs lower costs for responsible driving, making them a smart choice for saving money.
How to Improve Your Credit Score to Lower Insurance Costs
Pay Bills on Time
Paying bills on time helps improve your credit score. Payment history makes up 35% of your score. Late payments can hurt your score for seven years. Set up reminders or automatic payments to avoid missing bills. Paying on time shows responsibility, which insurers like.
Tip: Use a budgeting app to remember bill due dates.
Reduce Credit Card Balances
Using too much credit can lower your credit score. Experts say to keep usage under 30% of your limit. Paying down balances helps improve your score. For example, if your limit is $1,000, keep the balance below $300.
Note: Pay more than the minimum to reduce debt faster.
Check and Dispute Errors on Your Credit Report
Mistakes on credit reports can unfairly lower your score. Errors like wrong balances or old info are common. Check your report often to find mistakes. The law lets you dispute errors with credit bureaus. Fixing mistakes can quickly boost your score.
Action Step: Get free credit reports yearly at AnnualCreditReport.com.
Avoid Opening New Credit Accounts Unnecessarily
Opening new accounts can drop your credit score. Each application adds a hard inquiry to your report. Too many inquiries in a short time look bad. Focus on managing current accounts instead of opening new ones.
Reminder: Only apply for new credit when it’s truly needed.
Drivers with bad credit can still get cheaper car insurance. They should check different companies and learn how credit affects costs. Working on better credit, finding discounts, and comparing prices can help. Companies like GEICO or Nationwide offer good deals. Even if paying 93% more, affordable choices are available.
FAQ
How can I find cheap car insurance with bad credit?
Compare prices from different companies to save money. Look for discounts, choose higher deductibles, or try no-credit-check insurance plans.
Will fixing my credit score make car insurance cheaper?
Yes, better credit scores can mean lower rates. Insurers see high credit scores as less risky, so they offer cheaper prices.
Do some states ignore credit scores for car insurance?
Yes, states like California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts don’t allow credit scores to set rates. This helps drivers get fairer prices.
Tip: Check your state’s rules to see how credit scores affect insurance costs where you live.